1031 Exchange Commercial

February 16, 2024

Tim Clarke

1031 exchanges allow investors to sell commercial property and reinvest proceeds while deferring capital gains taxes. Strict ID and timing rules apply

As a seasoned real estate investor in North Carolina running a top-rated real estate team, I've helped numerous clients successfully execute 1031 exchanges to maximize returns and optimize taxes.

With over 17 years in the industry, I've developed specialized expertise guiding investors through the intricacies of these transactions.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll demystify 1031 exchanges so you can leverage these powerful tax-deferral tools in your own portfolio.

I understand the intricacies and tax advantages of properly executing a 1031 exchange.

Over years of guiding clients, I've found that many investors struggle to grasp the nuances of these complex transactions, so I have a more elementary explanation on the topic under "Tips For Investors". Click here.

Understanding the 1031 Exchange: Deferring Taxes and Growing Wealth

A 1031 exchange allows investors to sell an investment property, use all equity to acquire another like-kind replacement property, and defer paying capital gains taxes.

By continually rolling over equity into new investments, substantial wealth can be accumulated tax-free over long periods of time.

In our high-tax environment, deferring taxes on real estate sales through 1031 strategies is essential for optimizing returns.

Based on my expertise, investors able to compound gains tax-free over decades can end up with hundreds of thousands more in net worth.

As opposed to paying capital gains upon sale, a successful 1031 exchange allows taxes to be deferred indefinitely.

Taxes only need to be paid once you sell a property and don’t reinvest proceeds into another qualifying like-kind property via an exchange.

With wise planning, 1031 exchanges can be used repeatedly to build sizeable commercial real estate portfolios.

By consistently upgrading to more valuable property over multiple exchanges, net worth grows exponentially compared to being subject to taxes on each sale.

Eligibility and Qualifying Properties: Who Can Participate?

Now that I’ve underscored the immense financial benefits of 1031 exchanges, you’re probably wondering whether you’re eligible to participate.

Fortunately, the eligibility requirements are fairly straightforward:

  • The exchanger must be the legal owner of the property being sold/relinquished or exchanged. LLCs, partnerships, trusts, and other entities are also eligible.
  • Both the relinquished and replacement properties must be held for productive use in a trade, business, or investment. The intent should be to generate current or future income from the property.
  • The relinquished and replacement properties must be like-kind to qualify for full tax-deferral treatment. Within the realm of real estate investing, all property types are considered like-kind. This includes vacant land, residential rentals, retail centers, apartments, industrial warehouses, office buildings, etc. Properties outside the US don’t qualify.

Minor differences in property characteristics don’t necessarily disqualify an exchange as long as the nature and character of the property is fundamentally the same. There is wide latitude given “like-kind” status for real estate.

The Three Property Rule, 200% Rule, and 95% Rule: Maximizing Your Options

To fully optimize 1031 tax deferral benefits, it's important to understand key IRS rules including the three property rule, 200% rule, and 95% rule surrounding identification and reinvestment.

The three property rule stipulates that within 45 calendar days of selling the relinquished property, you can identify up to three potential replacement properties without regard to fair market value.

This provides wide flexibility finding suitable replacement property.

Additionally, the 200% rule allows you to identify more than three properties as long as their total value doesn’t exceed 200% of the relinquished property’s sales price. This further expands options.

Lastly, the 95% rule mandates that within 180 calendar days of the sale, you must reinvest at least 95% of your net sales proceeds into the replacement property to qualify for full tax deferral.

With a solid handle on these key regulations, investors can shop extensively for replacement property while ensuring full compliance.

Why Use a Qualified Intermediary?

To safely navigate the intricacies of 1031 exchanges, enlisting an experienced Qualified Intermediary (QI) is strongly advised.

QIs facilitate the entire exchange process while shielding investors from potential compliance pitfalls than can easily derail exchanges and eliminate tax benefits.

By using a QI, sale proceeds from the relinquished property are wired directly to the QI rather than the investor.

This prevents actual or constructive receipt of funds which would disqualify the exchange. The QI then disperses proceeds to acquire replacement property per the investor’s instructions.

In essence, QIs contractually assume control and safeguard exchange proceeds through the escrow process to ensure IRS guidelines are fulfilled.

Upon securing replacement property within statutory time limits, the QI wires funds to complete the purchase.

Reputable QIs like [Facilitator Name] can expertly guide investors through the entire exchange, providing experienced counsel and ensuring compliance.

This grants investors peace of mind through an extremely complex transaction with sizeable tax implications if miscued.

Finding and Engaging a Qualified Intermediary (QI): Simplify Your Exchange

When vetting Qualified Intermediaries, the following professional attributes and services should be strongly considered:

Reputation & Experience

Seek an established QI with abundant exchange transaction experience and expertise. They should have strong industry referrals and testimonials. Tenured experience navigating the complexities of exchanges is vital.

Attentive Service

The QI should be readily available to answer questions and offer consultative guidance through the exchange timeline. Timely, personalized service is crucial handling significant tax liability.

Safeguarding of Funds

Ask about account segregation and bonding safeguards to guarantee access to exchange proceeds. QIs should hold Exchange Funds in separate escrow accounts for security.

Expertise Meeting Deadlines

QI experience meeting rigid 45/180-day deadlines should be demonstrated. Missing deadlines has severe financial consequences.

Transaction Management

Full exchange facilitation services that coordinate all agreements, transfers of titles/deeds, and flow of funds between parties. Comprehensive transaction oversight is key.

By selecting a reputable QI, investors benefit tremendously from specialized compliance expertise. QIs help steer intricate exchanges for maximized tax deferral.

Navigating Identification & Time Limit Rules

As previously outlined, 1031 exchanges must adhere to strict IRS time limits including:

  • 45-Day Identification Period - Within 45 calendar days of closing on the sale of the relinquished property, up to 3 potential replacement properties must be identified in writing to the Qualified Intermediary.
  • 180-Day Exchange Period – Within 180 calendar days of closing on the sale, the new replacement property must be purchased via exchange completion.
  • If selling and buying involve the same counterparty in a simultaneous swap, this is condensed to 180 days including property identification.

With millions in potential tax liability at stake if time limits aren’t met, investors must plan exchanges carefully around these rigid deadlines.

Consult closely with your tax advisor and Qualified Intermediary to account for any delays or disruptions.

I advise clients to identify more than one suitable replacement property. This provides alternatives to fall back on if preferred properties have issues.

Leverage the 3 property and 200% rules to create ample selection flexibility meeting the 45-day limit.

Also budget ample time finding replacement property well before the 180-day deadline. Set a goal completing the exchange at least 30-60 days prior. This buffers for any title, lending, or other delays near the deadline.

With sound planning and preparation coordinated with experienced real estate tax counsel, 1031 exchange time limitations can be readily met.

Reinvestment Options & Requirements

Clients often ask me, "Tim, what kinds of real estate can I buy with the proceeds from selling my relinquished property to complete a 1031 exchange?"

This is an excellent question, because the IRS actually gives investors immense flexibility when it comes to redeploying funds into replacement property.

Acceptable replacement property investments include:

  • Raw land (for future development/resale)
  • Residential rentals
  • Multi-family apartments
  • Retail centers
  • Industrial facilities
  • Office buildings
  • Triple net leased properties
  • Commercial buildings
  • Farm/ranch real estate

Additionally, you can combine relinquished property proceeds with additional cash to purchase replacement property of greater value.

This allows you to continually “trade up” into higher value real estate holdings through successive tax deferred exchanges over time.

Lastly, the acquired equity percentage in replacement property must equal or exceed that which was sold to fully defer taxes.

If equity percentage is less, capital gains tax applies to the difference. Consult closely with your CPA/tax advisor on equity requirements.

With a solid handle on reinvestment guidelines, investors can keep proceeds actively invested in appropriate real estate.

Planning Ahead With Cost Segregation Studies

For substantial tax savings when eventually selling 1031 investment property, I always recommend Cost Segregation Studies to clients before acquisition.

Cost Segregation is an IRS-approved method accelerating depreciation deductions on shorter-life components of commercial property.

This includes elements with faster depreciation than standard 27.5 or 39 year real estate schedules. Think lighting, carpeting, cabinets, outdoor landscaping, security systems, etc.

By legally reclassifying these assets into shorter 5, 7, and 15-year schedules, substantial tax deductions are accelerated to the front end of ownership. This shields more income when the property is eventually sold.

Per IRS Revenue Procedure 2011-29, Cost Segregation can be conducted on properties acquired via 1031 for maximum benefit. Studies must be completed within 180 days of acquiring the replacement property, so advance planning is key.

Segregation Studies frequently generate 15-25%+ increases in annual depreciation deductions. The after-tax cash flow and tax deferral impacts are tremendous.

Understanding Tax Deferral and Cost Basis Adjustment

A core benefit of 1031 exchanges is tax deferral, not permanent tax elimination. The deferred tax liability carries forward to the new replacement property.

No taxes are assessed as long as you continue rolling over proceeds into additional like-kind investments.

Importantly, the cost basis and depreciation schedule resets with each successive exchange. State law varies on exactly how the cost basis adjusts. Consult closely with your CPA and Qualified Intermediary on state-specific technicalities.

In basic terms, cost basis becomes the purchase price paid for the replacement property, plus the carried-over deferral amount from the sale of the relinquished property, less any additional boot (non like-kind property or cash) received.

The deferred gain eventually becomes taxable once you sell investment property and don’t complete another qualifying 1031 exchange reinvesting full proceeds.

Historically, Congress has never retroactively rescinded 1031 exchange benefits, even when tax reform legislation was passed. This provides confidence in the perpetual use of exchanges.

Are You Jeopardizing Your 1031 Exchange?

While 1031 exchanges provide substantial tax deferral opportunities, investors must avoid common pitfalls jeopardizing beneficial treatment:

Actual or Constructive Receipt of Proceeds

Strict rules forbid exchangers from receiving sale proceeds or having funds accessible during the exchange timeline. All proceeds must flow through the Qualified Intermediary. Having access to funds triggers “constructive receipt” and immediate tax liability.

Attempting to Exchange Non Like-Kind Properties

Attempting to exchange your relinquished property for non “like-kind” real estate (ie. car wash, bowling alley, hotel, foreign property) fails to qualify for Section 1031 treatment.

Missing Identification/Exchange Deadlines

Exchangers must identify replacement property within 45 days and complete purchase within 180 days. Missing these rigid deadlines violates exchange requirements.

Comingling Exchange Funds

Qualified Intermediaries must keep exchange proceeds in dedicated escrow accounts, not commingled with the exchanger’s personal accounts. Co-mingling negates the validity of the exchange.

Purchasing Replacement Property from a Related Party

IRS rules prohibit buying replacement property from a related party, including your spouse, sibling, parent, or child.

There are some exceptions if the related party acquired the property over 2 years prior, but this should be discussed with your tax professionals.

Using Exchange Proceeds for Personal Benefit

You cannot use 1031 proceeds for personal benefit, pleasure, or consumption. Funds must be reinvested into qualifying real estate. Using funds for prohibited personal benefit disqualifies the exchange.

Completing a Taxable Sale Before the Exchange

You must initiate the 1031 exchange prior to closing on the sale of your relinquished property, or you lose the ability to defer taxes. The exchange structure must be set up first with assistance from your Qualified Intermediary.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Here are several other common pitfalls I counsel investors to avoid:

Not Planning the Second Leg

Some investors overly focus on the sale side of exchanges without properly planning for replacement property acquisition. Missing key details can cause the second leg to fail guidelines.

Changing Intent Mid-Exchange

You must have bona fide intent on replacing sold property with like-kind real estate initially and throughout the exchange. Shifting intent can invalidate the tax deferred status.

Failing to Identify All Transaction Costs

Accurately estimate all transaction, improvement and carrying costs related to replacement property to avoid coming up short on exchange proceeds.

Unexpected shortfalls can trigger tax liability if funds are reinvested into personal accounts to close gaps.

Providing Inaccurate Information to the QI

Always provide accurate information to your Qualified Intermediary. Inconsistencies or misinformation can severely disrupt exchanges and create liability.

Tax Implications and Deferral Benefits

If structured properly, 1031 exchanges allow investors to defer all federal and state capital gain taxes, recaptured deprecation, and depreciation recapture on relinquished investment property.

You still remain liable for applicable ordinary income taxes on recourse mortgage relief in excess of cost basis. Deferred gain liability also carries forward to replacement property.

But aside from these technical exceptions, 1031 exchanges facilitate immense tax deferral.

Based on my 17+ years in the industry, I estimate our 1031 exchange clients have cumulatively deferred over $10 million in capital gains taxes over the years. This provides more cash to funnel into productive real estate investments.

By deferring taxes until final property liquidation down the road, substantial wealth is built through compounding gains in successive exchanges. Our clients utilize 1031s specifically to multiply net worth well into retirement.

Final Thoughts From Tim

As an expert real estate professional who has guided clients through hundreds of 1031 exchanges during my 17 year career here in the Triangle region of North Carolina, I highly recommend partnering with us and an experienced tax specialist to ensure your exchange is completed properly.

My team and I focus on in-depth consultations to understand your investment goals, risk tolerance, and ideal replacement property characteristics.

We then leverage our extensive market knowledge and connections with lenders, attorneys, and Qualified Intermediaries to match you with suitable properties that align with your objectives.

Throughout the search process, we remain closely engaged - providing listings, arranging tours, overseeing inspections, coordinating transaction timelines with your Qualified Intermediary, and negotiating the best deal on your behalf.

We intimately understand the North Carolina real estate landscape and how to avoid common pitfalls that can derail exchanges.

With an intricate transaction like a 1031, having trusted local guidance is invaluable. As 30+ year Triangle residents, my team has our fingers on the pulse of emerging opportunities.

We know all the best areas to invest for optimal rentals, appreciation, and wealth building. Our repeat and referral business is unmatched thanks to our expertise and stellar client service.

To learn more about our end-to-end 1031 exchange concierge services, I encourage you to  contact us.

My team and I would be delighted to guide you through a smooth, tailored 1031 process so you can defer taxes and accomplish your real estate investment vision. Let's connect soon!

Frequently Asked Questions About 1031 Exchanges

What is a 1031 exchange?

A 1031 exchange, named after Section 1031 of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code, is a strategy that allows investors to defer capital gains taxes on the exchange of like-kind properties. This deferral includes any capital gains from the sale of the initial property by reinvesting in a similar property.

Does this mean 1031 exchanges are tax-free?

No, 1031 exchanges are not tax-free; they are tax-deferred. This means taxes on capital gains are postponed until the investor takes possession of the proceeds, potentially at a later sale.

Who qualifies for a 1031 exchange?

Owners of investment and business property – including individuals, C corporations, S corporations, partnerships, limited liability companies, trusts, and other tax entities – may set up an exchange of business or investment properties.

How do I know if I have the right properties for a 1031 exchange?

Both the property being sold (relinquished property) and the property being acquired (replacement property) must be held for productive use in a trade, business, or investment and must be like-kind. Like-kind refers to the nature of the investment rather than the form, and most real estate will be like-kind to other real estate, with some exceptions.

What does not qualify for a 1031 exchange?

Certain properties are excluded, even if used in trade or business or for investment. These include stocks, bonds, notes, securities, interests in partnerships, and inventory or property held primarily for sale.

Can an investment property be converted into a primary residence?

Yes, an investment property can be converted into a primary residence provided there was no intent to do so at the time of acquisition. The property must be held for a minimum of two years, and if rented, it must be at fair market value for 14 days or more each year.

What are the tax consequences when converting a replacement property in a 1031 exchange into a primary residence?

When a property that was part of a 1031 exchange is converted into a primary residence, it is subject to the Section 121 exclusion. This allows a 250,000 gain exclusion for singles and 500,000 for married couples filing jointly, provided the property is held for at least five years and was the taxpayer’s principal residence for at least two of those five years.

Is tangible and intangible personal property eligible for 1031 exchange treatment?

As of January 1, 2018, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act eliminated tangible and intangible personal property from Section 1031, meaning currently only real property is eligible for tax deferral.

Can I exchange property with a related party?

Exchanging property with a related party is generally discouraged by the IRS as it may trigger an audit. However, it is possible if certain conditions are met, including holding the acquired property for a minimum of two years.

How do I report a 1031 exchange to the IRS?

A 1031 exchange must be reported to the IRS using Form 8824 with your tax return for the year in which the exchange occurred. This form will detail the properties exchanged and the financial

Tim M. Clarke

About the author

17 years as a Realtor in the Research Triangle, Tim seeks to transform the Raleigh-Durham real estate scene through a progressive, people-centered approach prioritizing trust & transparency.

Contact Us

Looking to build / buy / sell in the Triangle? Drop us a line.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.