The Advantages of Different Types of Mortgage Lenders

February 16, 2024

Tim Clarke

Tips on choosing the right lender, loan officer & financing to simplify the process of buying your dream home with other people's money

Navigating the complex world of mortgage lending can be a daunting task for any homebuyer.

When faced with the question, "What kind of lender is best?" the response often depends on who you ask, and their advice might be influenced by their current employment or past experiences.

Real estate professionals and loan officers may have varying recommendations, with preferences shifting over time from portfolio lenders to mortgage bankers and brokers.

This article delves into the pros and cons of different types of mortgage lending institutions, emphasizing that while the institution's characteristics are important, the choice of a loan officer can be even more crucial.

A dependable and ethical loan officer can make a significant difference by acting as a knowledgeable advocate for the borrower.

With each type of lender offering unique strengths and weaknesses, the decision ultimately hinges on a combination of personal circumstances, the loan officer's expertise, and the specific offerings of the lending institution.

What kind of lender is best?

If you ask a loan officer, “What kind of lender is best?” the answer will be whatever kind of company he works for and he will give you a list of reasons why.

If you meet the same loan officer years later, and he works for a different kind of lender, he will give you a list of reasons why that type of lender is better.

REALTORS® will also have differing opinions, and those opinions have and will continue to change over time.

In the past, it seemed like most would recommend portfolio lenders. Now, they usually recommend mortgage bankers and mortgage brokers.

Most often they direct you to a specific loan officer who has demonstrated a track record of service and reliability.

This article discusses the advantages and disadvantage of different types of institutions, not the individual loan officers.

However, it is often more important to choose the correct loan officer, not the institution.

The loan officer has many responsibilities, one of which is to act as your representative and advocate to the lender he works for or the institutions he brokers loans to.

You want someone who has proven dependable and ethical in the past.

Regarding the institutions, the truth of the matter is that each type of lender has strengths and weaknesses.

This does not even take into account the variety of other factors that influence whether a lender is good or bad.

Quality can vary, depending on the loan officer, the support staff, which branch or office you are obtaining your loan from, and a variety of other factors.

Portfolio Lenders

Savings & Loans are quite often portfolio lenders, as are some banks. Portfolio lenders generally promote their own portfolio loans, which are usually adjustable rate loans.

They will often pay more compensation to their loan officers for originating a portfolio product than for originating a fixed rate loan.

You may also find that they are not as competitive as mortgage bankers and brokers in the fixed rate loan market.

However, it is often easier to qualify for a portfolio loan, so borrowers who may not qualify for a fixed rate loan may be able to obtain a loan from a portfolio lender.

A borrower may be able to qualify for a larger loan from a portfolio lender than he could obtain from a fixed rate lender.

Portfolio lenders also can serve as niche lenders because certain things are more important to them than meeting the more standardized underwriting guidelines of a mortgage banker.

An example would be a savings & loan, which is more concerned with an individual’s savings history than being able to fully document income and other things.

If you apply for a loan with a portfolio lender and you are declined, you usually have to start the process over with a new company.

Mortgage Bankers

If we are talking about the larger mortgage bankers, you can count on them having several strengths. For the biggest ones, you will recognize the brand name.

Usually, they are much better at promoting special first time buyer programs offered by states and local governments, that have lower interest rates and costs than the current market rate.

These programs are often available to buyers who have not owned a home in the last three years and fall within certain income guidelines.

Mortgage bankers may incur problems because they are just too big to manage, or they may operate like well-oiled machines.

If you are buying a home and you need a VA or FHA loan and the development you are buying in has not yet been approved, they will be better at getting it approved than other lenders.

If your home loan is declined for some reason, many mortgage bankers allow their loan officers to broker the loan to another institution.

However, because your loan officer is so used to promoting the company’s product, he may not be familiar with which institution may be the best one to submit your loan to.

Another reason is because wholesale lenders do not expect to get many loans from direct mortgage bankers, so they do not expend much marketing effort on them.

Mortgage Brokers

The major strength of mortgage brokers is that they can shop the wholesale lenders for the best rate much easier than a borrower can.

They also learn the “hot points” of certain wholesale lenders and can handpick the lender for a borrower that may be unique in some way.

He will be able to advise you whether your loan should be submitted to a portfolio lender or a mortgage banker.

Another advantage is that, if a loan gets declined for some reason, they can simply repackage the loan and submit it to another wholesale lender.

One additional advantage is that mortgage brokers tend to attract a high number of the most qualified loan officers.

This is not universal because mortgage brokers also serve as the training ground for those just entering the business.

If you have a new loan officer and there is something unique about you or the property you are buying, there could be a problem on the horizon that an experienced loan officer would have anticipated.

A disadvantage is that mortgage brokers sometimes attract the greediest loan officers, too.

They may charge you more on your loan, which would then nullify the ability of the mortgage broker being able to shop for the lowest rate.

Banks and Savings & Loans

Their major strength is that you will recognize their name.

In addition, they will usually be operating as a mortgage banker, a portfolio lender, or both, and have the same weaknesses and strengths.

Wholesale Lenders

Borrowers cannot get access to the wholesale divisions of mortgage bankers and portfolio lenders without going through a broker.

Hard Money Lenders

Hard money lenders are a specific type of financing option for real estate investors and developers.

These non-institutional private lenders provide loans that are secured by the real estate property itself rather than looking primarily at the borrower's creditworthiness.

Hard money loans typically have higher interest rates and fees compared to conventional bank financing, but they also have more flexible qualifying guidelines.

Investors often use these loans as short-term bridge financing to renovate or reposition a property before selling or refinancing into longer-term loans.

Hard money lenders focus less on credit scores and debt-to-income ratios and more on the property's potential resale value.

Their underwriting decisions center around the loan-to-value ratio based on an appraised after-repaired value.

Hard money fills a lending niche for time-sensitive real estate deals that don't fit traditional loan criteria.

When REALTORS® or Builders Recommend a Lender

If your REALTOR® or builder makes a suggestion for a lender, be sure to talk to that lender.

One reason REALTORS® and builders make suggestions is the fact that they have regular dealings with this lender and have come to expect a certain amount of reliability.

Reliability is extremely important to all parties involved in a real estate transaction.

On the other hand, a recent trend in mortgage lending has been for real estate companies and builders to own their own mortgage companies or create “controlled business arrangements” (CBA’s) in order to increase their profitability.

These mortgage brokers sometimes become used to having what is essentially a captured market and may not necessarily offer you the lowest rates or costs.

Some real estate companies also offer different types of incentives to their REALTORS® in exchange for recommending their company-owned mortgage and escrow companies or lenders with whom they have CBA’s.

Dealing with one of these lenders is not necessarily a bad thing, though.

The builder or real estate company often feels they have more ability to expedite matters when they own the company or have a controlled business relationship.

They cannot usually influence the underwriting decision, but they can sometimes cut through red tape to handle problems or speed up the process.

Builders are especially forceful on having you use their lender. One reason is that there are certain intricacies in dealing with new homes.

If you use a loan officer who usually deals with refinances or resale home loans, he may not even be aware of how different it is to close a mortgage on a new home and this can lead to problems or delays.

It is in your interest to know if there is any kind of ownership relationship or controlled business arrangement between the real estate or builder and the lender, so be sure to ask.

Do not automatically disqualify such a lender, but be sure to be more vigilant on getting the best interest rate and the lowest costs.

Final Thoughts From Tim

As a veteran real estate agent in the Triangle area, I've helped countless clients finance their home purchases over my 17 year career.

With many types of lenders and loans available, it can get overwhelming determining the best option.

My advice is to find an experienced loan officer you connect with and trust to explain the pros and cons of different loans.

Be upfront about your financial situation and goals.

As a first-time homebuyer or someone with past credit issues, alternative lending routes like portfolio loans or hard money may help you qualify.

Just be prepared for higher interest rates and costs.

If going the traditional mortgage route, work with your loan officer to get pre-approved before house hunting.

This helps you know your budget and how much home you can afford. Provide all requested paperwork in a timely manner for a smoother underwriting process.

Rates and programs change frequently, so once you find a home, lock your rate quickly.

I've found local community banks and credit unions like State Employees Credit Union (SECU) to have great service and competitive rates without some of the bureaucracy of mega lenders.

But no matter the lending institution, having patience, staying organized with all correspondence, and communicating openly with your loan officer, real estate agent, and other partners will lead to a less stressful transaction.

With the right education and team, financing with "other people's money" can make your dreams of homeownership a reality.

Tim M. Clarke

About the author

17 years as a Realtor in the Research Triangle, Tim seeks to transform the Raleigh-Durham real estate scene through a progressive, people-centered approach prioritizing trust & transparency.

Contact Us

Looking to build / buy / sell in the Triangle? Drop us a line.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.